Middle East Studies Association Salutes University of California Press for Publishing Beyond Chutzpah

December 7, 2005

In News


At its 70th board meeting in November 2001, MESA’s board of directors
established the MESA Academic Freedom Award, to be presented on appropriate occasions in recognition of sustained contributions to the promotion and defense of academic freedom in the Middle East and North Africa. In 2005 the Committee proposed making two awards, and the Board has agreed with this recommendation.

The first of our 2005 Academic Freedom Awards goes tonight to Fatma Muge Gocek of the University of Michigan and Ron Suny of the University of Chicago, and all the scholars associated with the Workshop for Armenian-Turkish Scholarship, in recognition of their successful collective effort, using the tools of history and the social sciences and relying on the language of collegial discourse, to initiate and implement a project that overcame political divisions in society and in the academy and has provided a model that others addressing other conflicted histories can use in the years ahead.

In the year 2000, these scholars initiated a series of conferences between
Armenian, Armenian-American, Turkish and Turkish-American historians and
specialists that addressed issues raised by the 1915 destruction of the
Ottoman Empire’s Armenian population. In September 2005 they achieved a
noteworthy milestone when Istanbul’s Bilgi University hosted some members
at a conference on these issues, also organized by Bogazici and Sabanci
universities, despite considerable opposition from a number of political
leaders and groups in Turkey.

MESA celebrates their efforts as an elegant example of how academic
freedom works and why it must be protected and promoted. We trust
that their efforts will serve as a model to be emulated elsewhere.

Please join me in saluting the strong collective work of the Workshop
on Armenian-Turkish Scholarship, recipients of a MESA Academic
Freedom Award for 2005.

MESA tonight also salutes the Iranian writer Akbar Ganji, a major
figure in promoting intellectual and political debate in the Islamic
Republic over much of the past ten years and a man who has paid an
enormous price for his efforts by spending the last five of those
years in some of the country’s most notorious prisons and cell
blocks. Although Akbar Ganji is not affiliated with an academic
institution, his resistance to repression of intellectual freedom
in Iran has been crucial to sustaining intellectual debate there.

Akbar Ganji is the author of Dungeon of Ghosts and A Republican
, among other works. He is currently serving a six-year
prison sentence handed down in 2001 for “acting against national
security” and “spreading propaganda,” among other charges stemming
from his writings critical of the government. The Iranian authorities
have held him in solitary confinement almost continuously since
September 3 in a special ward of Tehran’s Evin prison. Even today,
from prison, his letters and manifestos inspire people in Iran and
around the world who struggle for a future free of arbitrary power.
Please join the CAF tonight in recognizing Akbar Ganji, a public
intellectual and writer of uncommon courage, and recipient of a
2005 MESA Academic Freedom Award.

Finally, I and the Committee want to use this occasion to cite
and congratulate the University of California Press, and its
director Lynne Withey, for seeing to completion the publication
of Dr Norman Finkelstein’s book, Beyond Chutzpah: On the Misuse
of Antio-Semitism and the Abuse of History
, despite considerable
and concerted efforts to prevent that from happening. For this
MESA’s Committee on Academic Freedom salutes the Press and all
those who made this happen.