CHICAGO — An embattled professor’s fight to return to his classroom at DePaul University amid criticism for his views on the Holocaust ended quietly Wednesday after he agreed to resign immediately.
Norman Finkelstein, the son of Holocaust survivors, threatened to risk arrest by showing up on the first day of classes but negotiations with university officials led to a peaceful exit.
DePaul, a private Chicago Catholic university, recently informed Finkelstein that his three courses were canceled after being denied tenure in June after six years as a faculty member.
“I felt finally I had gotten what was my due and maybe it was time for everybody’s sake that I move on,” Finkelstein said at a press conference on campus where he issued a joint statement with DePaul.
A confidentiality agreement reached by Finkelstein and DePaul withheld terms of the settlement.
Critics find issue with Finkelstein, the son of Holocaust survivors, who believes that some Jews have exploited the legacy of the Holocaust.
The university, which called Finkelstein a “prolific scholar and an outstanding teacher,” said outside parties, including Harvard Law Professor Alan Dershowitz, who weighed in on Finkelstein, did not influence its decision to deny tenure. Finkelstein wrote a book criticizing Dershowitz’s “The Case for Israel.”
“Professor Finkelstein has expressed the view that he should have been granted tenure and that third parties external to the university influenced DePaul in denying tenure. That is not so,” according to a joint statement reached between Finkelstein and DePaul University. DePaul will not comment further past the statement.
“I was denied tenure due to external pressures climaxing in a national hysteria that tainted the tenure process,” Finkelstein said in the statement.
Finkelstein thanked the group of about 100 students wearing “We are all Professor Finkelstein” t-shirts in support of their beloved professor.
“I had some very dark moments. And yet everytime I walked into the classroom, however awful the moment was, my spirits were lifted seeing my students,” Finkelstein said.
Andrew Riplinger, who showed up to support his favorite professor, was dropped from one of his classes.
“The students are really hurt by all of this,” Riplinger, a political science and psychology senior at DePaul.
“I don’t think that our role is done,” said Kathryn Weber, president of the Academic Freedom Committee, a registered student group that organized amid the tenure debate to support Finkelstein. Weber also took two of Finkelstein’s classes.
Finkelstein doesn’t know what he is going to do next, but he said he’s leaving “this school with my dignity intact.”
More articles on tenure denial:
- The Chronicle of Higher Ed: A reliable source (06.04.2007)
- Raul Hilberg: “I have a sinking feeling about the damage this will do to academic freedom…” (Chicago Tribune, 06.10.2007)
- Chronicle of Higher Ed on Settlement (Finkelstein comments: “The Chronicle mistakenly represents the statement of DePaul University as our joint statement. We issued separate statements (click the banner headine on this web site for these statements).”) 09.06.2007
- Video from DePaul Farewell (YouTube.com: “Norman Finkelstein’s Statement; AFC: Student Protest March”) 09.06.2007
- Bloomberg News on Tenure Settlement (”DePaul’s Finkelstein Quits After Being Denied Tenure (Update1)”) 09.06.2007
- Chicago Sun-Times on tenure settlement (Chicago Sun-Times: “Professor’s ‘nightmare’with DePaul is over. CRITIC OF ISRAEL | After long fight, scholar bows out”) 09.06.2007
- Inside Higher Ed on tenure settlement (Inside Higher Education: “Finkelstein and DePaul Settle”) 09.06.2007
- Tribune on Tenure (Chicago Tribune: “Finkelstein deal ends DePaul tiff”) 09.06.2007
- AP on Tenure (The Associated Press: “Embattled DePaul Prof Agrees to Resign”) 09.06.2007
- DePaul acknowledges Finkelstein “prolific scholar and outstanding teacher” (”Joint statement of Norman Finkelstein and DePaul University on their tenure controversy and its resolution”) 09.05.2007
- Fox News: “Embattled DePaul Professor Resigns, Leaves University Quietly” 09.05.2007
- Chicago Tribune & International Herald Tribune on settlement (Chicago Tribune: “DePaul, embattled professor settle dispute. As Finkelstein resigns, university calls him ‘an outstanding teacher’”) 09.05.2007
- DePaul students protest in front of Dean’s office (The Associated Press: “Embattled DePaul professor returns to campus”) 09.05.2007
- Finkelstein on latest smear (”Quick Takes: …Why DePaul Wants Finkelstein Gone…”) 09.04.2007
- The smear campaign begins - but it won’t work (Chicago Tribune: “DePaul memos tell of run-ins with professor”) 09.03.2007
- The Washington Times: ‘Denied tenure, DePaul professor planning protests’ 09.02.2007
- How not to succeed at being clever while really trying (Andrew Sullivan: ‘Leon Wieseltier put it best when he referred to Norman Finkelstein–the hysterical, Hezbollah-loving, soon-to-be-late-of DePaul University political science professor–as “poison, he’s a disgusting self-hating Jew, he’s something you find under a rock.”‘; 09.02.2007)
- Chicago IndyMedia: “Photos from [DePaul's] Convocation protest” (09.02.2007)
- Chicago Sun-Times: ” Denial of tenure defended” (09.01.2007)
- AcademicFreedomChicago.org: “A Battle for the Soul of DePaul, and for the Future of Academia: An Open Letter to DePaul Faculty “ (08.31.2007)
- Fox News: “Controversial Professor Plans to Risk Arrest After University Cancels His Classes” (08.30.2007)
- The Guardian: “Holocaust academic vows to fight axe of university class” (08.30.2007)
- Inside Higher Education: “Terminating the Terminal Year” (08.28.2007)
- The Chicago Tribune: “DePaul pulls plug on controversial professor. Course cancelled a week before class” (08.28.2007)
- The Chronicle of Higher Education: “DePaul U. Cancels Courses of Professor Who Lost Tenure Bid, but He Plans to Teach Them Anyway” (08.28.2007)
- AAUP writes DePaul yet again (08.27.2007)
- DePaul’s latest outrage (08.27.2007)
- How DePaul practices Vincentian values (08.25.2007)
- DePaul Students Put Administration on Notice: We Will Defend Academic Freedom! (08.23.2007)
- Another robust message from AAUP to DePaul (08.22.2007)
- Another letter to DePaul’s President (08.20.2007)
- A letter to DePaul’s President (08.16.2007)
- DePaul Students write President Holtschneider (DePaul Academic Freedom Chicago: “Norman Finkelstein’s right to return to teach,” 08.15.2007)
- A detailed analysis of Depaul’s tenure decision (”ACADEMIC FREEDOM ON TRIAL: NORMAN FINKELSTEIN AND THE MINORITY REPORT,” 08.10.2007)
- DePaul Faculty Comments on Tenure Decision (Bill Martin, Professor of Philosophy at DePaul, DissidentVoice.org: “Urgent Need to Right Wrongs at DePaul University,” 08.09.2007)
- RESOLUTION OPPOSING DEPAUL UNIVERSITY’S DECISION TO DENY TENURE TO DR. NORMAN FINKELSTEIN AND DR. MEHRENE LARUDEE (08.02.2007)
- AAUP v. Father Holtschneider (of Depaul) (07.28.2007)
- American Association of University Professors letter (07.25.2007)
- Letter from former student to DePaul (07.25.2007)
- Protesting Norman Finkelstein’s Tenure Denial; or, Academic Freedom Declines across the U.S. - Part II” (07.15.2007)
- If the Stairs Do Fit, You Cannot Acquit (Finkelstein comments: “The DePaul administration now alleges that I am a Menace II Society. To prove this allegation, they have…”, 07.03.2007)
- More photos from DePaul students (07.03.2007)
- Letter from a student at Harvard Law School (07.03.2007)
- Interesting revelations, interesting speculations (CounterPunch: “Anatomy of a Smear: The Commissar Two-Step at DePaul,” 07.02.2007)
- Photos and more from DePaul students “Who is John Simon?…” (07.02.2007)
- Resolution presented to US Social Forum (Atlanta) (07.02.2007)
- “The ‘F-Word’- How DePaul Is Terrified Of Anything Finkelstein” (Chicago Indymedia, 06.29.2007)
- A DePaul Faster Speaks (CounterPunch: “Academic Injustices: Fasting for Justice at DePaul,” 06.29.2007)
- A Reasoned Statement on Tenure Denial (CounterPunch: “”The Poisoning of Academic Freedom: Strange Calculus at DePaul,” 06.28.2007)
- [DePaul students'] FAST UPDATE (06.30.2007)
- Iran on Tenure Denial (06.26.2007)
- Chronicle on DePaul Fast (06.25.2007)
- Dersh again: “Finkelstein’s Sexism” (06.25.2007)
- Letter to DePaul President Holtschneider about Student Fast (06.25.2007)
- Al-Hayat on Tenure (06.24.2007)
- The plot thickens (Chicago Sun-Times: “Outwit. Outplay. Outlast. Outtenure?” 06.22.2007)
- Vancouver Jewish Group on Tenure (06.21.2007)
- CounterPunch: “Student Anger at the Denial of Tenure for Two Progressive Professors. Boycotting DePaul” (06.22.2007)
- Video: Aljazeera on tenure (06.21.2007)
- A letter to Father Holtschneider (06.19.2007)
- NBC5 | WMAQ TV, Chicago: “DePaul Students Turn Graduation Into Protest w/ video segment (06.19.2007)
- Counter Punch: Fallout from a Smear: Finkelstein and The Progressive (06.16.2007)
- DePaul Student Statement to Faculty (06.14.2007)
- Harvard Crimson on Tenure Denial (06.17.2007)
- Chicago Sun-Times: “Students ordered to leave chief’s area” (06.14.2007)
- Chicago Sun-Times: “DePaul chief may face vote of no confidence” (06.13.2007)
- Students Call for Rally to Defend Academic Freedom (06.13.2007)
- ChicagoPublicRadio.org, Eight Forty Eight: “Dr. Norman Finkelstein joins us to reflect on DePaul University’s decision to deny him tenure.” (06.12.2007)
- The Jerusalem Post: “US Jewish prof. refused tenure due to Shoah views” (06.11.2007)
- DePaul Students Take a Stand - by Sitting In! (06.12.2007)
- Inside Higher Education on Tenure Denial (06.11.2007)
- The (British) Guardian on Tenure Denial (06.11.2007)
- The New York Times on tenure denial (06.11.2007)
- Anti-Defamation League on tenure denial (06.11.2007)
- Jewish Telegraphic Agency on Tenure Denial (06.11.2007)
- Chicago Sun-Times, The Chronicle of Higher Education News Blog, the Associated Press on tenure denial (06.08.2007)
- Tenure? (4 articles: The Chronicle of Higher Education, Inside Higher Ed, The Harvard Crimson, FrontPageMag.com)
- Chomsky on Dershowitz, Finkelstein and tenure
- Holocaust scholar Raul Hilberg & Israel scholar Avi Shlaim on tenure
- No tenure for Finkelstein!
- Fisk on Tenure
- National Catholic Reporter on Tenure
- PLAUT ON TENURE
- On Dershowitz and Finkelstein
- Princetonian on tenure
- Tenure and the Times
- Jerusalem Post on tenure
- Jewish Week on Tenure
- JDO Launches Campaign “Operation Drive Out!” to Drive Self-Hating Jewish Professor Hater of Israel- Mocker of the Holocaust- Out of De Paul University
- The Nation on Tenure
- Dershowitz in Wall Street Journal on tenure
- CUNY on Tenure
- Fox News on tenure
- Chicago Tribune on tenure
- Chicago Sun-Times on tenure
- Tenure, from a mile high
- Comment on Tenure
- Alan Dershowitz and Peter Novick in Chronicle of Higher Education on Tenure
- Chicago Jewish News on Tenure
- Bangkok Post: Witch hunt
- JTA on anti-tenure petition


























